Losing weight, one diet at a time; one month at a time…
Thin Doesn’t Equal Healthy
I was talking to my husband, Adam this morning about what to write a post about today (not even through January and I’m already out of ideas! UGH). He rattled off a few ideas and then he started complaining about his weight. Now Adam is 6ft tall and maybe 170 lbs – not exactly obese or even overweight. So, I roll my eyes at him – because I have the perpetual 20-30 lbs that I need to lose – really! And he comes back at me and exclaims “just because a person is skinny, doesn’t mean that they’re healthy”. And, he’s right.
He has a naturally high metabolism and he’s definitely active – yard work, shoveling massive amounts of snow, bike riding, etc. His diet is about the same as mine – not necessarily watching what we’re eating like we should be, but he doesn’t gain weight. But, he has high cholesterol and this can be a serious health issue. In fact, I’m 20lbs overweight according to the charts for my age and height, but my cholesterol is fine.
We always seem to assume that heavy = unhealthy and I suppose, in general that can be true as we hear all the time the diseases and conditions that obesity play a huge roll in. But, we rarely think about those who appear to be “healthy” may actualy have as many health issues as those of us with weight to lose.
Thanks for listening.
| Print article | This entry was posted by lizzie on January 19, 2010 at 3:32 pm, and is filed under Weight Loss Ramblings. Follow any responses to this post through RSS 2.0. Both comments and pings are currently closed. |
Comments are closed.

about 2 years ago
Perfect article, as always
about 2 years ago
Your husband is a wise man. And yes, there are very few of us (at least where I am, in the US of A) who couldn’t stand to make some improvement in our diet, whether it’s related to weight loss or otherwise.
about 2 years ago
i am not so fat so i am satisfied with this blog. those who are thing should read this especially
capitalpower.org
about 2 years ago
Great Article. I have only Just found your blog but I will definately be coming back again! Keep writing! Jen
about 2 years ago
well..in my country there are some assuming that the thin person is not healthy or we can say it, it doesn’t fully fit body
about 2 years ago
We always seem to assume that heavy = unhealthy and I suppose
about 2 years ago
Trying to lose weight atm and this helps alot. thanks;)
about 2 years ago
Nice blog, a lot of useful articles
about 2 years ago
I agree with you on the issue that those who look healthy might have serious health issues as those who need to lose weight. My mum is a typical example, really slim but with a high blood pressure
about 2 years ago
Hey. Nice article you have written here.
My advice so loose weight is to stop the diet and instead start a ew way to eat. Don’t stop eating choclate and candy, just eat less than you are used to.
about 2 years ago
I agree with your husband. I hate walking. Its because I am lazy. Now I am about 100 pounds. I suffer a lot.
about 2 years ago
Great post. We as human are naturally lazy when it comes doing anything that makes us work hard. I am a coach and i struggle to convince my athletes sometimes to finish their workouts, though they know the benefits but they still need to be pushed.
Likewise losing weight especially abdominal fat is hard, but can be done with enough self discipline and will. I believe in moderation of everything including food because i have seen it works.
about 2 years ago
I have to totally agree with your sentiments – thin does not mean healthy. Not only thin does not mean healthy, it can be hugely unattractive too. Just today I saw a girl / woman in I’d image her 30s. While she has the potential to look very attractive she was just so think, almost baby like. The skeletal frame on her was just, I say it loosely, ‘gross’. Just as unappealing as someone who is overweight and bed-ridden.
about 2 years ago
great article as always and your husband is really a wise man i always make plans for exercise and diet but everyday keeps on delaying it.
about 2 years ago
I agree with your husband as well. Actually seems like my husband and I, about 6’3 and weighs 167 lbs, and me who can stand to loose about 15lbs. I workout 4 times a week and love the healthy veggies and such. My husband has to force veggies and vitamins down, for the most part healthy though. There are too many judgments as to what people need to look like! Thanks for sharing. The ideas will keep coming, I know the feeling.
about 2 years ago
not always the fat body is not healthy
about 2 years ago
No thin doesn’t = healthy but heavy is a factor in diabetes and heart disease and such.
about 2 years ago
This is absolutely right. I fully agree.
about 2 years ago
That is a very nice informative article. keep going. I like that.
about 2 years ago
This is very true. Health is directly proportional to wealth. Health depends upon your level of energy and activeness. If you are thin and collapse then you are not healthy. Nice article
emergencyvehiclelightsstore.com
about 2 years ago
I meant health is not directly proportional to weight.
about 2 years ago
Thanks for your good post. I will share of my all friends. This content will be helpful for obese people.
about 2 years ago
The main thing is to have a healthy heart, so as long as you are doing something to elevate your heart rate for 20 or 30 minutes 2 or 3 times a week then you should be ok. The fact that thin doesn’t necessarily mean healthy is well demonstrated by anorexics.
about 2 years ago
interesting article , I do know notice that in winter I catch colds and stuff alot more when i have less mody fat , lets say I keep myself more rip…I agree that its about having a healthy balance not too fat not too thin…
about 2 years ago
My daughter is 11 and over weight. She wants to loose some serious weight over the summer. Have any tips or suggestions?
about 2 years ago
I totally agree with you, thin nor fat has nothing to do with being healthy. No one knows what is going on inside our bodies. the only way to stay fit and healthy is by eating healthy foods and doing a little exercise on a daily basis.
I have written about you on my blog, I do hope you will take some time out to read what I wrote… You can read my post here…
http://www.weightlosscoach-alexandri.com/thin-does-not-equal-healthy/
Keep up the posting, your blog is really nice,
Alexandri Flor
Weight Loss Coach
about 2 years ago
I understand that the location of fat, particularly for men must be considered, big thighs and buns is healthier than the beer belly look ( involving the Omentum). That beachball on toothpicks look is not the most attractive either.
about 2 years ago
It’s just a matter of time for m. I don’t have the time to do some sports and it’s hard to find it but I do know that I have to change this.
about 2 years ago
I totally agree with your husband too.. stop diet and get more exercise is the good way
about 2 years ago
Our health has direct relation with our body weight. Thanks for your sharing.
about 2 years ago
I’ve been a serial dieter all my life, and I just gotten fatter and fatter. I am now trying the intuitive eating approach, it is quite nice. I am not bingeing anymore. I am not dieting either, the weight is coming down but slowly
about 2 years ago
I am also trying to lose weight and this post helps a lot as well as give me some positive thoughts. thanks and all the best;)
about 2 years ago
great post, some people overweight cant help it…
about 2 years ago
Lovely article. I have only just found your blog but Im already a big fan.
about 2 years ago
You are 100% spot on. Being thin does not guarantee health. In fact, I’d say nothing guarantees health (no diet, no bodyweight).
about 2 years ago
There is nothing like guarantee in the dictionary of health i am sure….harish@underground dog fence
about 2 years ago
Nice Blog !! You have great collection of article … Keep writing
about 2 years ago
I have never thought about that before, but yes that is true! Thank you for opening my eyes and giving myself more confedence in my appearance. I will continue to live my life being healthy by staying active. Thank you!
about 2 years ago
I think attitude and happiness are also huge factors for health. A happy person is most of the time way healthier than an unhappy one.
Thanks for the article love to see new views!!!
about 2 years ago
Its now the 1st of Febuary. Curious to know how many people have given up on their new year diet resolution.
about 2 years ago
Not being obese doesnt guarantee good health….
hm@The Pink Candy for Healthy Life
about 2 years ago
Certainly, being thin does not mean being healthy.
Going on a crash cource diet is no good either.
about 2 years ago
well skinny or even “sexy” doesn’t guarantee healthy at all.
all we can do build a good habits
sport, eating plan, sleep habit, etc etc
thanks
about 2 years ago
It’s absolutely true that thin does not equate to being healthy!
Cholesterol and Fats are not the same thing. A person that is fat does not necessarily has a high cholesterol level and likewise, person that is thin need not mean that he would have low cholesterol level.
about 2 years ago
Great article! I have gone through one article and i found awesome tips to lose our weight.With less effort we can melt our fat.We should take 8 glasses of water on right time.
2 glass:when we wake up
1 glass :before breakfast
1 glass:after breakfast
1 glass:before lunch
1 glass:after lunch
1 glass:before dinner
1 glass:after dinner
I am trying to follow this thread in order to reduce my fat belly and to become healthy.So i don’t know what will be the result but i found this method simply the best where we don’t need to work hard and use any side-effect things.Your article is simply awesome therefore i love your blog a lot.Thanks a lot for sharing.
about 2 years ago
Weight has been a problem to many people and they really want to get rid of these things. You need to exercise a lot and work on your body well enough to loose weight. It is a good and informative article.
about 2 years ago
I can speak from experience. Had I followed proper diets when I was younger I might not have been battling all the cancers I am today
about 2 years ago
I forwarded this two several people who maintain a ‘healthy’ weight through unhealthy habits. Seriously, I have friends risking lung cancer and osteoporosis just to stay at a ‘healthy’ weight!
about 2 years ago
never underestimate the benefits of a proper diet!
about 2 years ago
Proper diet is the only way to avoid lots of health issues
about 2 years ago
We as human are naturally lazy when it comes doing anything that makes us work hard. I am a coach and i struggle to convince my athletes sometimes to finish their workouts, though they know the benefits but they still need to be pushed.
about 2 years ago
Natural diet using fruits is the best way to reduce some weight and also it is healthy too!
about 2 years ago
Yep I believe everyone needs to make themselves more healthy.
about 2 years ago
Being slim does not mean being healthy is a very true fact. I witness a lot of it around it, through some of my friends that have gotten sick after massive weight loss. Losing weight should be a natural normal process, and not something resulted from starvation or absurd dieting.
about 2 years ago
Thankfully here in the UK we`re beginning to see `real` women being used as models on TV, not the stick thin so-called ideal shape that is too often seen on the catwalks.
about 2 years ago
Good to visit your site.i always make plans for exercise and diet but everyday keeps on delaying it. Keep writing
about 2 years ago
That’s right, thin doesn’t mean healthy of course. You need to exercise, get all the vitamins and shit. I do cardio at home everyday and eat a healthy diet, I feel good now as always
about 2 years ago
Your husband made a very good point. It’s true, I have friends who are skinny, they do eat a lot but don’t get fat,but unhealthy. There are just people who doesn’t get fat because their bones are small but living unhealthy.
about 2 years ago
Yes your husband is definitely right but that’s mostly not an average case. In any case, its true that the faster your metabolism is to burn calories doesn’t make someone healthy. I think people need to consider this more often
about 2 years ago
This is definitely true. Our appearance is only a small part when determining out overall health. Just take smokers, for example. I’m sure there are tons of “healthy” looking smokers out there, but they certainly aren’t at their prime.
about 2 years ago
Wow, you make me sound so good..6ft. at last measuring I was 5’11″..lol…
Yes, my good cholesterol is really too low..My doc says I need to start exercising regularlly..I was thinking about taking some martial arts classes this winter, since I can’t go to a gym.
It might also help if I reduced the amount of icecream that I eat..a really big weakness.
about 2 years ago
I was told by a nurse today (after a blood test a couple of weeks ago), that cholesterol should be between 2 and 6. Mine was 4.2, though I do take statins every day to control it.
about 2 years ago
Remind your husband about the merits of walking. Body weight can be kept in control when one expends calories via physical exercise like walking. You can find lot of articles related to walking benefits on net. Try to show him all and make aware of walking.
about 2 years ago
Hey, I think I am the best friend for your husband. I am also lazy with walking.
about 2 years ago
Really good and informative post,can be very helpful but if a person becomes pro-active about their diet and daily exercise can easily return back to a normal lifestyle.Thanks for the recommendation.
about 2 years ago
Once a qigong master said that fit did not mean healthy. We were quite shocked to hear that. He said that healthy means all the organs and bodily functions were good. Fit meant that strong, and able to walk, run etc.
about 2 years ago
OK, I am actually to heavy right now. But I am a firm believer that to thin is as unhealthy as to big. Now I went on a diet and weighed 170 at 6 ft. And I was always tired and never had any energy. I decided to start eating a little more and went up to 200 lbs, and I felt great. I had a ton of energy and could do things at 200 lbs that i couldn’t do at 170. So to me that is my optimal weight even though doctors say I should be at 170- 180.
about 2 years ago
Definately, each different person has their different body type. Being thin doesn’t definately means health. What matters maintian a healthy body and BMI so you don’t have too much fat or too little fat. As with anything in life moderation is very important. Also when trying to lose weight moderate changes are the way to go.
about 2 years ago
The title of this post is absolutely true that ‘thin doesn’t equal healthy’.I believe that if person is thin or fat,it is more important to be healthy.Sometimes a thin person also has health problems which is not good.To be healthy,it is better to eat healthy food.
about 2 years ago
According to to me, if someone is healthy, then they aren’t “fat”. They may be overweight, but not fat. Many of my friends are overweight, but you can tell by looking at them that they’re healthy. They don’t look fat, they look great.
about 1 year ago
Absolutely true! My husband is 5’11 and has gone up and down the scale, but still has high blood pressure. We’ve come to thinking that it’s no longer the weight. So now, we focus more on what we eat and what he does. He’s gone back to playing basketball to keep active. Throw that weighing scale away! He of course, has to keep taking his meds just to be sure. If any of you need additional help in coping with health, you’re always welcome to our shop. We deliver only in US though..
about 1 year ago
The fact that he is active and moves all day not only helps keep his weight reasonable, but helps keep him healthy! If you are thin only because your metabolism is fast and you eat unhealthy foods, you are not healthy. Eat well, move well, think well
about 1 year ago
That’s very true but I would rather be skinny with health issues then fat with the same health issues
But I think everyone should keep an eye on there health skinny or not. Thanks for the post
about 1 year ago
I have to agree with your boyfriend, he told you some wise words. It´s really important to have right balanse in life, if you´re skinny it does´nt meen you are healthy.
For almost 3 years now I have been doing a work out program that´s really Really works. And offcourse I eat healthy too.
Say Hello to your boyfriend from me!
Take care
about 1 year ago
Sorry, I disagree with most of it. At least 6 of the top 10 biggest killers are obesity or overweight related diseases, such as hypertension, stroke, diabetes, various types of cancer, and heart disease. All of which a thinner person generally (and proveably) has a much lower chance of developing.
As a NATURALLY (and that is the key word) skinny person myself, I don’t believe I could honestly be any fitter, and my measured blood fat levels (esp. triglycerides) were some of the best the doctor had ever seen. My resting pulse rate/breathing rate is also slow (slower is better) and my blood pressure is below average but not too low.
Most other people I know are much less fit than me, and always seem to be getting colds far more too. That blows the theory that thinner people have worse immune systems out of the water. All the fatter people at my work place seem to be taking the most “sick days” off.
I have a long line of naturally skinny ancestors in my family, and all of that build have surpassed the age of 90 years.
I just think a lot of the people here are jealous of naturally skinny people who genuinely can eat what they want without having to watch the pounds or worry about health problems, because they are burning the calories off not storing them as fat. Sour grapes.